PIZZA PIZZA GUIDE
PIZZA PIZZA GUIDE
Showcasing Our Wide Variety of Local Pie Options : There Are Plenty of Delicious Places to Choose a Pizza From In Ellicottville ... Which Ones Do You Love?
STONE-FIRED SENSATIONS
John Harvards Brew House: 6447 Holiday Valley Rd : EVL, 716.699.5350, holidayvalley.com
If you’re up golfing, biking or hiking at the Valley and your tired legs just can’t get you all the way back into town, you can always book your reservation for John Harvard’s Brewhouse, located inside the Tamarack Club. They’ve got a brand new summer menu and the pizza options are amazing. Go Very Veggie, Buffalo Chicken or maybe be brave a try the Prosciutto and Pear. You can add Mike’s Hot Honey to any pie for .75¢ and gluten free crust is always available. Part of their menu is also available in the Holiday Valley Cabana Bar!
DIVINE DESSERT
EBC Little Valley Pub & Pizzeria: 202 2nd St. : Little Valley, 716.699.2537, ellicottvillebrewing.com/locations
The newest Ellicottville Brewing location in Little Valley, NY focuses on amazing brick oven pizza and pub fare like Brett’s Burger. You can indulge in pizza queso dip, burrata salad and build your own pie from their variety of toppings, super customizable. But don’t forget dessert. EBC doesn’t stop at regular pizza. They also have a scrumptious selection of dessert pizza, like cannoli, peach, and their special strawberry fields (whipped honey marscapone, local strawberries macerated in elderflower syrup and farm fresh basil leaves). Dinner and dessert in pizza form - now that’s where it’s at!
PIZZA PARTY
Tim and Bonnies EVL: 8 Bristol Lane : EVL, 716.699.9021, timandbonnies.com
Tim and Bonnie’s has become a local staple, synonymous with wings, subs and pizza. They’ve got all the basics. From cheese and pep and taco pizza to their ever popular Famous Steak Pizza (an oil based pie with grilled black Angus beef, sautéed mushrooms, onions and your choice of peppers with a combination of American, Parmesan, mozzarella and Fontinella cheese) You can order up a personal for your lunch time needs or snag a sheet pizza for your next big party and please the whole family with pizza for all!
PROVOCATIVE PIZZA
Dina’s Restaurant: 15 Washington St. : EVL, 716.699.5330, dinas.com
You can’t talk about pizza in Ellicottville without mentioning Dina’s Restaurant. They’ve been turning out fabulous pies for a long time and you shouldn’t miss out on the experience. Grab a Judy (roasted garlic, olive oil, lemon, spinach, sun-dried tomato, mozzarella and feta) or The Big Al (meat lovers favorite, featuring bacon, sausage, pepperoni and mozzarella). You definitely don’t want to miss the specialty options like the Surf & Turf Pizza when it’s offered. Tiger shrimp, prosciutto, pesto and cheese, sign yourself right up for that!
PIZZA PERFECTION
West Rose: 23 Washington St : EVL, 716.699.9113, westrose.restaurant
West Rose is a powerhouse of pizza perfection. Featuring traditional pepperoni to gourmet offerings like Delicata Squash with garlic cream, truffle pecorino, mozzarella, caciocavallo, red onion and oregano. Their 3-cheese is a twist on a classic with garlic cream sauce, crushed pistachio, Aleppo pepper and honey. Their newest creation was a special, confit potato pizza with wood roasted onions and rosemary. So many unique and tasty options to choose from. Do yourself a favor and pick one up this weekend.
COMFORTABLE & CLASSIC
Katy’s Fly-In: 4836 Route 219 : EVL, 716.265.2040, Facebook.com/katysflyin
Take a short tip to Great Valley, NY for a stop at a local’s favorite. Katy’s Fly-In is a family restaurant with a lot of variety that serves up breakfast, lunch and dinner. Of course they offer classic red sauce pizza with all the usual toppings. A comfortable classic option for those who enjoy keeping it simple. Or take your basic cheese and pepperoni and add mushrooms, peppers, sausage (plus many more toppings) for more variety for your pie. Don’t forget to include a side of crispy chicken wings to go with it. (Except on Friday, no wings on fish fry days)
PIZZA APLENTY
Steelbound Brewery & Distillery: US Route 219 : EVL, 716.699.2042, steelboundevl.com
If you’re looking for a pie that is as unique as you can be, then Steelbound Brewery and Distillery is the place for you. They’ve got the usual suspects of cheese & pep and veggie but they are also slinging a Stuffed Pepper Pizza, a Sweet and Savory featuring poached peaches and herbed cream cheese and their almost famous 3 Little Pigs Pizza. That is pork sausage, chopped bacon, prosciutto, marscapone, cheese blend and arugula, all together. Sounds like you should be making an order for a couple right now!
BRICK-OVEN BEAUTIES
Monroe Street Brick & Brew: 21 Monroe St • EVL, 716.699.1051, monroestpizza.com
Monroe Street Brick & Brew prides itself on brick oven cooked pizza and wings in a relaxing environment. Beautifully blistered homemade thin crust topped with a selection of fresh ingredients. From traditional Margherita to their Bricks Hawaiian (red sauce, cheese, red onion, prosciutto, pineapple and balsamic glaze), MSBB will delight your pizza palate. You can also customize your own pizza creation. Don’t forget to order some brick oven bread sticks, wings, or a calzone. If you’re feeling boring, you could also always order a salad.